Saturday, October 30, 2010

Québec water caselaw 15: Earthworks in a wetland without a valid municipal authorisation

(BY HUGO)

In Rivière-Rouge (Ville de) v. Huguet (in French), the Defendant obtains a municipal authorisation to do earthworks on his property in the riparian area of a lake. The works starts on the same day, but a municipal inspector visiting the site realises that the filling is taking place in a wetland, something contrary to the municipal regulation. The municipality immediately informs the Defendant that the authorisation is cancelled and that the work must stop at once. Despite this, the Defendant goes ahead with the earthworks during the following days despite continued warnings from the municipality.

The defendant is charged with a penal infraction in strict liability for having done work without a valid authorisation a contravention to the municipal regulation. Although municipal authorities are not bound by an authorisation granted contrary to the municipal regulation, as is the case in this instance, the municipal inspector does not have the power to stop the works under the applicable municipal regulation. Moreover, the municipal regulation does not allow the municipal inspector to revoke the authorisation. Nevertheless, an illegal authorisation does not grant an acquired right, and the infraction the Defendant faces is to have conducted works without a valid permit. The Court finds that the Defendant has no defence of reasonable diligence, as he understood that municipality asked the works to stop but he rushed to complete the works to put the municipality before a fait accompli.

No comments:

Post a Comment